Player Awards
| 2045 | Legend of the Game | Gary Farr | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2045 | Coach of the Year | Gregory Langan | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2045 | Player of the Year | Kendall McCarthy | Oregon Bandits |
| 2045 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Daquan Allen | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2045 | Offensive Player of the Year | Sam Hiatt | Texas Inferno |
| 2045 | Defensive Player of the Year | Hugh Zeller | Detroit Vampires |
| 2045 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Kenneth Crawford | Oregon Bandits |
| 2045 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Griffin Smith | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Kendall McCarthy | Oregon Bandits |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Running Back | Sam Hiatt | Texas Inferno |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Fullback | Josh Hamernik | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Tight End | Cole Jones | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Antonio Duncan | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Caleb Purnell | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Center | Raymond Spurgeon | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Marty Carlisle | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Theodore McGraw | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Martin Godfrey | Ohio Sentries |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Donovan Joyner | Hartford Attack |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Punter | Quentin Godfrey | Miami Talons |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Kicker | Jose Whittington | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Jimmy Brady | Miami Talons |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Jonah Stokley | Boston Blizzard |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Al Kelly | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Lee Perez | Shreveport Pride |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Arnold Griffith | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Hugh Zeller | Detroit Vampires |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Griffin Smith | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Bubba Beuter | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Mercury Toma | Hartford Attack |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Safety | Joseph Hughes | Miami Talons |
| 2045 | All-League First Team Safety | Hudson Monroe | Kansas City Storm |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Gary Farr | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Jeffrey Allard | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Doug Owens | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Horace Hayes | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Shaquille Oakes | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Morris Tatum | Shreveport Pride |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Center | Mo Read | Texas Inferno |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Max Perroni | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Jeffrey Rickertsen | Seattle Spartans |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Reuben Cassell | Tennessee Militia |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Mercury Eisner | Seattle Spartans |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Punter | Grayson Collins | Shreveport Pride |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Brian Sanford | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Cedric Powell | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Richie Crow | Oregon Bandits |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Jorge Wolf | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Stan Simmons | Oregon Bandits |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Demetrius Baylor | Tucson Toros |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Andrew Wrighster | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Archie Bunker | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Asher Hamner | Shreveport Pride |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Tre Alkateeb | Miami Talons |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Safety | Ty Wolfsmith | Detroit Vampires |
| 2045 | All-League Second Team Safety | J.R. Cunningham | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2045 | League's Fastest Man | Dixon Powell | Boston Blizzard |
| 2045 | League's Strongest Man | Reuben Cassell | Tennessee Militia |
| 2044 | Legend of the Game | Marco Boese | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2044 | Coach of the Year | Stevie Spano | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2044 | Player of the Year | Gary Farr | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2044 | Front Office Bowl MVP | R.J. Gibson | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2044 | Offensive Player of the Year | Gary Farr | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2044 | Defensive Player of the Year | Bernard Dixon | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2044 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Shaquille Oakes | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2044 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Hugh Zeller | Detroit Vampires |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Gary Farr | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Running Back | Steven Negron | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Fullback | Fernando Elling | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Tight End | Cole Jones | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Morris Tatum | Shreveport Pride |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Deon Tyree | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Center | Raymond Spurgeon | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Theodore McGraw | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Max Perroni | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Bryson Nichols | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Martin Godfrey | Ohio Sentries |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Punter | Bart Hughett | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Kicker | George Kooiker | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Jimmy Brady | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Bubba Gray | Tucson Toros |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Bubba Walton | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Al Kelly | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Asher McWilliams | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Bernard Dixon | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Hugh Zeller | Detroit Vampires |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Josh Van Pelt | Boise City Stampede |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Myles Arnold | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Safety | J.R. Cunningham | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2044 | All-League First Team Safety | Harold King | Ohio Sentries |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Kendall McCarthy | Oregon Bandits |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Rylan Hahn | Detroit Vampires |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Brendan Wolfe | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Rusty Willig | Tennessee Militia |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Howie Knight | Oregon Bandits |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Toby Hartman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Center | Hugh Quinn | Tucson Toros |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Marty Carlisle | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Hayden Ciarleglio | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Kyle Franz | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Barry Davis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Punter | Peter Whitmire | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Jose Whittington | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Randy Farmer | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Glen Foreman | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Justics Goodwin | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Floyd Pfeiffer | Oregon Bandits |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Blake Barlow | Kansas City Storm |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Brant Tyler | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Archie Bunker | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Kirk Fundinger | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Bubba Beuter | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Safety | Hudson Monroe | Kansas City Storm |
| 2044 | All-League Second Team Safety | Wendell Hickman | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2044 | League's Fastest Man | Deon Tyree | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2044 | League's Strongest Man | Blake Rayburn | Seattle Spartans |
| 2043 | Legend of the Game | J.B. Lynch | Miami Talons |
| 2043 | Coach of the Year | David McKoy | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2043 | Player of the Year | Gary Farr | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2043 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Marshall Woodard | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2043 | Offensive Player of the Year | Gary Farr | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2043 | Defensive Player of the Year | Harold King | Ohio Sentries |
| 2043 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Teddy Lyon | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2043 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Demetrius Baylor | Tucson Toros |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Gary Farr | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Running Back | Jeffrey Allard | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Fullback | Fernando Elling | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Tight End | Cole Jones | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Caleb Purnell | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Toby Hartman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Center | Raymond Spurgeon | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Theodore McGraw | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Max Perroni | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Barry Davis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Rickey Meske | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Punter | James Tyler | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Kicker | J.R. Stargell | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Ricky Hoffman | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Jimmy Brady | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Rufus Gozzi | Seattle Spartans |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Al Kelly | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Demetrius Baylor | Tucson Toros |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Kim Bain | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Juan Borders | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Roman Bryant | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Moe Vanderlaan | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Safety | Harold King | Ohio Sentries |
| 2043 | All-League First Team Safety | Hudson Monroe | Kansas City Storm |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Marshall Woodard | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Kenny Sanders | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Lonnie Bruce | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Gerald Harbert | Kansas City Storm |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Deon Tyree | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Ike Nakajo | Shreveport Pride |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Center | Bruce Johnston | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Bo Donaldson | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Marshall Hurst | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Bryson Nichols | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Kyle Franz | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Punter | Quentin Godfrey | Miami Talons |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Jose Whittington | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Ronnie Cash | Boise City Stampede |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Joseph Westphal | Hartford Attack |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Tevin Spaulding | Kansas City Storm |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Floyd Pfeiffer | Oregon Bandits |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Dana de los Santos | Tennessee Militia |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Floyd Russell | Boston Blizzard |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Dusty Handy | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Doug Lykins | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Darren Dussault | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Safety | Joseph Hughes | Miami Talons |
| 2043 | All-League Second Team Safety | Wendell Hickman | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2043 | League's Fastest Man | Randall Lyle | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2043 | League's Strongest Man | Taylor Walker | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2042 | Legend of the Game | Rondell Whiting | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2042 | Coach of the Year | Brian Lore | Hartford Attack |
| 2042 | Player of the Year | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2042 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Rondell Whiting | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2042 | Offensive Player of the Year | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2042 | Defensive Player of the Year | Harold King | Ohio Sentries |
| 2042 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Sam Hiatt | Texas Inferno |
| 2042 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Floyd Russell | Boston Blizzard |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Running Back | Ethan Cabrera | Ohio Sentries |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Fullback | Mel Griffey | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Tight End | Gerald Harbert | Kansas City Storm |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | A.J. Martin | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Gino Wynn | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Center | Raymond Spurgeon | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Patrick Huffman | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Percy Andrus | Denver Dynomite |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Barry Davis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Kyle Franz | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Punter | Cleve Chong | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Kicker | Rickey Craig | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Ronnie Cash | Boise City Stampede |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Daniel Cho | Boston Blizzard |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Avery Terrell | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Al Kelly | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Renaldo Raymond | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Archie Bunker | Ohio Sentries |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Eric Lenhardt | Denver Dynomite |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Rickey Benitez | Oregon Bandits |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Darren Dussault | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Safety | Harold King | Ohio Sentries |
| 2042 | All-League First Team Safety | Karl Bernard | Tucson Toros |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Gary Farr | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Benjamin Hawkins | Tucson Toros |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Deion Bishop | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Cole Jones | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Howie Knight | Oregon Bandits |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Toby Hartman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Center | Austin Harrison | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | B.J. Montgomery | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Max Perroni | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Mercury Eisner | Seattle Spartans |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Eric Holmes | Oregon Bandits |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Punter | Quentin Godfrey | Miami Talons |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Juan Patterson | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Jesse Kotomski | Shreveport Pride |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Winston Harper | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Will Nickle | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Earl Talley | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Ryan Shelton | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Dominic Castillo | Tennessee Militia |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Kendall Blackwell | Detroit Vampires |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Josh Van Pelt | Boise City Stampede |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Luther Watkins | Hartford Attack |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Safety | Norman Richmond | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2042 | All-League Second Team Safety | Marlon Summerfield | Shreveport Pride |
| 2042 | League's Fastest Man | Caleb Purnell | Kansas City Storm |
| 2042 | League's Strongest Man | Cole McQuistan | Seattle Spartans |
| 2041 | Legend of the Game | Blaine Barrett | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2041 | Coach of the Year | Brian Lore | Hartford Attack |
| 2041 | Player of the Year | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2041 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Monty Lynch | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2041 | Offensive Player of the Year | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2041 | Defensive Player of the Year | Jimmy Brady | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2041 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Benjamin Hawkins | Tucson Toros |
| 2041 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Asher McWilliams | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Running Back | Kenny Sanders | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Fullback | Deion Bishop | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Tight End | Ronnie Farrell | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Toby Hartman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Howie Knight | Boston Blizzard |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Center | Raymond Spurgeon | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Bo Donaldson | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Max Perroni | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Kyle Franz | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Mercury Eisner | Seattle Spartans |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Punter | Quentin Godfrey | Miami Talons |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Kicker | Pepper Wilburn | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Jimmy Brady | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Dale Chandler | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Floyd Pfeiffer | Oregon Bandits |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Rufus Gozzi | Seattle Spartans |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Charles Shepard | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Archie Bunker | Ohio Sentries |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Glen Kitts | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Jon Dandron | Hartford Attack |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Cornell Jones | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Safety | Hudson Monroe | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2041 | All-League First Team Safety | Wendell Hickman | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Gary Farr | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Jeffrey Allard | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Carl Snyder | Seattle Spartans |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Dusty Hawkins | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Wally Wooden | Shreveport Pride |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Mark Clemons | Kansas City Storm |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Center | Marshall Daniels | Shreveport Pride |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Joshua Wyss | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Deon Whiteside | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Bryson Nichols | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Barry Davis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Punter | Brent Schoeppner | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Larry Cryer | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Rufus Keene | Hartford Attack |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | A.J. Newhart | Kansas City Storm |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Kelly Sides | Boise City Stampede |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Christian Robbins | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Blake Barlow | Kansas City Storm |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Dominic Castillo | Tennessee Militia |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Sherman Schultz | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Rickey Benitez | Oregon Bandits |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Zack Henderson | Miami Talons |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Safety | Kendrick West | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2041 | All-League Second Team Safety | Jim Wilcox | Boise City Stampede |
| 2041 | League's Fastest Man | Myron Goodwin | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2041 | League's Strongest Man | Jack Conley | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2040 | Legend of the Game | Desmond Cobb | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2040 | Player of the Year | Andrew Adamo | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2040 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Gerald Morton | Boise City Stampede |
| 2040 | Offensive Player of the Year | Andrew Adamo | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2040 | Defensive Player of the Year | Ronnie Cash | Boise City Stampede |
| 2040 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Jeffrey Allard | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2040 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Hudson Monroe | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Running Back | Andrew Adamo | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Fullback | Deion Bishop | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Tight End | Cole Jones | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Mark Clemons | Kansas City Storm |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Toby Hartman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Center | Raymond Spurgeon | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Earnest Halvorson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Spencer Anderson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Kyle Franz | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Barry Davis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Punter | Roman Clinton | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Kicker | Chad Malone | Boise City Stampede |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Ronnie Cash | Boise City Stampede |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Daniel Cho | Boston Blizzard |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Floyd Pfeiffer | Oregon Bandits |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Lee Perez | Miami Talons |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Butch Ellison | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Archie Bunker | Ohio Sentries |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Sherman Schultz | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Luther Watkins | Hartford Attack |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Darren Dussault | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Safety | J.R. Cunningham | Detroit Vampires |
| 2040 | All-League First Team Safety | Jim Wilcox | Boise City Stampede |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Desmond Cobb | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Running Back | J.T. Stargell | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Thomas Grier | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Dusty Hawkins | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Wally Wooden | Shreveport Pride |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | A.J. Martin | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Center | Austin Harrison | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Dwight Madsen | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Camden Bodden | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | John Dunn | Boise City Stampede |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Antonio Guzy | Miami Talons |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Punter | Brent Schoeppner | Ohio Sentries |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Pepper Wilburn | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Winston Harper | Tennessee Militia |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | A.J. Newhart | Kansas City Storm |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Will Nickle | Shreveport Pride |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Benjamin Holmes | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Rondell Cormier | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Kendall Blackwell | Detroit Vampires |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Kent Grosz | Hartford Attack |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Blaine Togiai | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Dixon Mickus | Detroit Vampires |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Safety | Ronnie Bonney | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2040 | All-League Second Team Safety | Sam Webb | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2040 | League's Fastest Man | Toby Hartman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2040 | League's Strongest Man | Sedrick Janjic | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2039 | Legend of the Game | Emmanuel Cole | Tennessee Militia |
| 2039 | Player of the Year | Kenny Sanders | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2039 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Howard Nixon | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2039 | Offensive Player of the Year | Omar Huffman | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2039 | Defensive Player of the Year | Eric Lenhardt | Denver Dynomite |
| 2039 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Cornelius Qaderi | Tennessee Militia |
| 2039 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Nicholas Jacobs | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Quarterback | J.B. Lynch | Miami Talons |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Running Back | Omar Huffman | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Fullback | Zach Wheeler | Tennessee Militia |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Tight End | Bob Solano | Hartford Attack |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Toby Hartman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | A.J. Martin | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Center | Hugh Quinn | Tucson Toros |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Bo Donaldson | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Max Perroni | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Mercury Eisner | Seattle Spartans |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Terrance Wayne | Kansas City Storm |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Punter | Howard Doyle | Boston Blizzard |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Kicker | Rickey Craig | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Daniel Cho | Boston Blizzard |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Herb Money | Boise City Stampede |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Floyd Pfeiffer | Oregon Bandits |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Brenden Maloney | Kansas City Storm |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Dominic Castillo | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Eric Lenhardt | Denver Dynomite |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Kendall Blackwell | Detroit Vampires |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Lonnie Megorden | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Darren Dussault | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Safety | Harold King | Ohio Sentries |
| 2039 | All-League First Team Safety | Arnold Reinert | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Gary Farr | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Jamie Glaros | Tucson Toros |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Lonnie Bruce | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Tight End | R.J. Alston | Miami Talons |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Damon Barker | Miami Talons |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Myron Goodwin | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Center | Jeff Hansen | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Julio O'Donnell | Tennessee Militia |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Percy Andrus | Denver Dynomite |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Barry Davis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Jerald Ross | Tennessee Militia |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Punter | Terry Burgower | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Jose Whittington | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Winston Harper | Tennessee Militia |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Tom Harvey | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Darren Lyon | Texas Inferno |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Rufus Gozzi | Seattle Spartans |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Dean Iannucci | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Corey Fisher | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Rusty Weiser | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Amos Eppright | Boston Blizzard |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Mack Randle | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Safety | Blaine Watson | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2039 | All-League Second Team Safety | J.R. Cunningham | Detroit Vampires |
| 2039 | League's Fastest Man | A.J. Martin | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2039 | League's Strongest Man | Cole McQuistan | Seattle Spartans |
| 2038 | Legend of the Game | Donnell Fields | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2038 | Player of the Year | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2038 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Timothy Kiser | Denver Dynomite |
| 2038 | Offensive Player of the Year | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2038 | Defensive Player of the Year | Harold King | Ohio Sentries |
| 2038 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Joe Wombacher | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2038 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Shawn Elliott | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Running Back | Tarzan Hernandez | Hartford Attack |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Fullback | Brett Furrer | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Tight End | Carlos Polhemus | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Toby Hartman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Wayne Lett | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Center | Raymond Spurgeon | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Bo Donaldson | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Leland Schneider | Oregon Bandits |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Kyle Franz | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Barry Davis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Punter | Terry Burgower | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Kicker | Emmanuel Batts | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Herb Money | Boise City Stampede |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Tom Harvey | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Lamont Gardner | Boise City Stampede |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Nathan Thornhill | Tucson Toros |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Charles Shepard | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Heath Clayton | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Dale Fletcher | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Cornell Jones | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Carlton Hucke | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Safety | Harold King | Ohio Sentries |
| 2038 | All-League First Team Safety | Harris Kelly | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Rico Lynn | Shreveport Pride |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Andrew Adamo | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Daryl McClinton | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Tight End | R.J. Alston | Miami Talons |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Ray Bradley | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Gino Wynn | Tennessee Militia |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Center | Anthony Golalic | Hartford Attack |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Max Perroni | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | J.B. Gerhardt | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Billy Burroughs | Oregon Bandits |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Jerald Ross | Tennessee Militia |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Punter | Bart Hughett | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Larry Cryer | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Brock Harpold | Tucson Toros |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Daniel Cho | Boston Blizzard |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Floyd Pfeiffer | Oregon Bandits |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Les Finch | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Perry Hopper | Tucson Toros |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Joseph Holliday | Boise City Stampede |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Corey Fisher | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Rickey Benitez | Oregon Bandits |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Seth Hutchins | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Safety | Anthony Bjorkstam | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2038 | All-League Second Team Safety | Shawn Elliott | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2038 | League's Fastest Man | Harold King | Ohio Sentries |
| 2038 | League's Strongest Man | Jorge Cerqua | Ohio Sentries |
| 2037 | Legend of the Game | Ray Parmely | Ohio Sentries |
| 2037 | Player of the Year | Eugene Paulk | Tucson Toros |
| 2037 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Zach Shipway | Hartford Attack |
| 2037 | Offensive Player of the Year | Eugene Paulk | Tucson Toros |
| 2037 | Defensive Player of the Year | Dale Fletcher | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2037 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Kenny Sanders | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2037 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Sherman Schultz | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Eugene Paulk | Tucson Toros |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Running Back | Junior Wolfe | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Fullback | Deion Bishop | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Tight End | Alex Campbell | Tennessee Militia |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | A.J. Martin | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Howie Knight | Boston Blizzard |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Center | Spencer Barnes | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Bo Donaldson | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Spencer Anderson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Jon Gaylor | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Thomas Lyon | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Punter | Wendell Campo | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Kicker | Brett Riddle | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Ron Mathis | Boston Blizzard |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Defensive End | A.J. Newhart | Kansas City Storm |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Floyd Pfeiffer | Oregon Bandits |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Rufus Gozzi | Seattle Spartans |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Terrance Farley | Denver Dynomite |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Dale Fletcher | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Corey Fisher | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Cornell Jones | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Darren Dussault | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Safety | Harold King | Ohio Sentries |
| 2037 | All-League First Team Safety | Joey Stephenson | Miami Talons |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Mickey Mutzel | Kansas City Storm |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Hunter Dail | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Carlos Polhemus | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Walt Long | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Wally Wooden | Shreveport Pride |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Center | Roderick Herndon | Detroit Vampires |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | J.B. Gerhardt | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Earnest Halvorson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Marcus Durham | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Barry Davis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Punter | Colin Andrews | Boise City Stampede |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Rickey Craig | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Ronnie Cash | Boise City Stampede |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Brock Harpold | Tucson Toros |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Vinny Corrigan | Hartford Attack |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Arnold Lyle | Boise City Stampede |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Walter Josephson | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Cornelius Lynch | Shreveport Pride |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Joseph Holliday | Boise City Stampede |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Britt Perkins | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Shaun Bailey | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Safety | Anthony Bjorkstam | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2037 | All-League Second Team Safety | Jim Wilcox | Boise City Stampede |
| 2037 | League's Fastest Man | Moe Vanderlaan | Oregon Bandits |
| 2037 | League's Strongest Man | Max Perroni | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2036 | Legend of the Game | Warren Prescott | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2036 | Player of the Year | Junior Wolfe | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2036 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Rico Fitzpatrick | Hartford Attack |
| 2036 | Offensive Player of the Year | Junior Wolfe | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2036 | Defensive Player of the Year | Edwin Stoner | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2036 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | J.T. Stargell | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2036 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Harold King | Ohio Sentries |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Eugene Paulk | Tucson Toros |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Running Back | Junior Wolfe | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Fullback | Deion Bishop | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Tight End | Alex Campbell | Tennessee Militia |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Walt Long | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Toby Hartman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Center | Anthony Golalic | Hartford Attack |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Bo Donaldson | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Earnest Halvorson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Thomas Lyon | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Terrance Wayne | Kansas City Storm |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Punter | J.R. Choate | Kansas City Storm |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Kicker | Chad Gaytan | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Brock Harpold | Tucson Toros |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Matthew Burton | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Lamont Gardner | Boise City Stampede |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Tracy Mosby | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Charles Shepard | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Edwin Stoner | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Joseph Holliday | Boise City Stampede |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Britt Perkins | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Roman Drake | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Safety | Brant Kasper | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2036 | All-League First Team Safety | Harold King | Ohio Sentries |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Tarzan Hernandez | Hartford Attack |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Mickey Sims | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Cris Cooke | Detroit Vampires |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Sam Martinez | Hartford Attack |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Jim Brost | Tucson Toros |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Center | Spencer Barnes | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Spencer Anderson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Teddy O'Neal | Hartford Attack |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Kyle Franz | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Jerald Ross | Tennessee Militia |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Punter | Chad Malek | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Brett Riddle | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Leland Wellins | Shreveport Pride |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Herb Money | Boise City Stampede |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Floyd Pfeiffer | Oregon Bandits |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Christian Robbins | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Perry Hopper | Tucson Toros |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Kent Grosz | Hartford Attack |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Brandon Stockman | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Hardy Cook | Seattle Spartans |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Dixon Mickus | Detroit Vampires |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Safety | Joey Stephenson | Miami Talons |
| 2036 | All-League Second Team Safety | Anthony Bjorkstam | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2036 | League's Fastest Man | Wally Wooden | Shreveport Pride |
| 2036 | League's Strongest Man | Marcus Durham | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2035 | Legend of the Game | Ricky Demps | Boston Blizzard |
| 2035 | Player of the Year | Harry Reese | Texas Inferno |
| 2035 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Rico Fitzpatrick | Hartford Attack |
| 2035 | Offensive Player of the Year | Harry Reese | Texas Inferno |
| 2035 | Defensive Player of the Year | Charles Shepard | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2035 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Mickey Mutzel | Kansas City Storm |
| 2035 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Harris Kelly | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Harry Reese | Texas Inferno |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Running Back | Tarzan Hernandez | Hartford Attack |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Fullback | Hunter Dail | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Tight End | Rufus Walsh | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Ray Bradley | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Wally Wooden | Shreveport Pride |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Center | Jeff Hansen | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Bo Donaldson | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Earnest Halvorson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Kyle Franz | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Jerald Ross | Tennessee Militia |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Punter | Alonzo Spires | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Kicker | Tyrus Wooden | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Leland Wellins | Shreveport Pride |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Tito Kaitola | Kansas City Storm |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Floyd Pfeiffer | Oregon Bandits |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Jerry Ryder | Detroit Vampires |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Charles Shepard | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Cornelius Lynch | Shreveport Pride |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Mark Seubert | Detroit Vampires |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Britt Perkins | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Joel Hudrlik | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Safety | Anthony Bjorkstam | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2035 | All-League First Team Safety | Brant Kasper | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Eugene Paulk | Tucson Toros |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Junior Wolfe | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Mickey Sims | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Alex Campbell | Tennessee Militia |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | A.J. Martin | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Walt Long | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Center | Anthony Golalic | Hartford Attack |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Van Fitzgerald | Tennessee Militia |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Ernest Ward | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Rodney Lynn | Hartford Attack |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Sam Parrish | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Punter | Melvin Grant | Ohio Sentries |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Pepper Wilburn | Denver Dynomite |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Jessie Ager | Seattle Spartans |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Jesse Watson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Tracy Mosby | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Desmond Macri | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Randy Terrell | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Brandon Stockman | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Dale Fletcher | Denver Dynomite |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Calvin Baxter | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Ian Suto | Boston Blizzard |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Safety | Teddy Solymos | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2035 | All-League Second Team Safety | Dean Cooksey | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2035 | League's Fastest Man | John Yancy | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2035 | League's Strongest Man | Oliver Hanley | Kansas City Storm |
| 2034 | Legend of the Game | Zach Bertolini | Oregon Bandits |
| 2034 | Player of the Year | Tarzan Hernandez | Hartford Attack |
| 2034 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2034 | Offensive Player of the Year | Tarzan Hernandez | Hartford Attack |
| 2034 | Defensive Player of the Year | Heath Clayton | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2034 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | David Browning | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2034 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Jim Wilcox | Boise City Stampede |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Rico Lynn | Oregon Bandits |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Running Back | Tarzan Hernandez | Hartford Attack |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Fullback | Nate Atkins | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Tight End | Alex Campbell | Tennessee Militia |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Jim Brost | Tucson Toros |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Gino Wynn | Oregon Bandits |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Center | Vincent Harter | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Bo Donaldson | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Earnest Halvorson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Kyle Franz | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Donny Wolf | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Punter | Wendell Campo | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Kicker | Emmanuel Batts | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Mercury Emmons | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Tito Kaitola | Kansas City Storm |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Floyd Pfeiffer | Oregon Bandits |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Julio Sturgell | Denver Dynomite |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Charles Shepard | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Heath Clayton | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Dale Fletcher | Denver Dynomite |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Marvin Loniewski | Kansas City Storm |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Britt Perkins | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Safety | Joey Stephenson | Miami Talons |
| 2034 | All-League First Team Safety | Travis Chapman | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Eugene Paulk | Tucson Toros |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Bart Godfrey | Tennessee Militia |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Shane Beleford | Seattle Spartans |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Claude Fox | Seattle Spartans |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | A.J. Martin | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Louie Hopkins | Detroit Vampires |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Center | Daryl Fagelman | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Shaun Ethridge | Denver Dynomite |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Van Fitzgerald | Tennessee Militia |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Clarence Washburn | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Antonio Guzy | Miami Talons |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Punter | Melvin Grant | Boise City Stampede |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Kicker | A.J. Lageman | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Leland Wellins | Shreveport Pride |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Clarence Mills | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Tracy Mosby | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Warren Prescott | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Luther Howard | Boise City Stampede |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Troy Beauchamp | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Tyrus McChane | Miami Talons |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Rickey Johnston | Hartford Attack |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Kelvin Bunyan | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Safety | Jim Wilcox | Boise City Stampede |
| 2034 | All-League Second Team Safety | Ronnie Bonney | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2034 | League's Fastest Man | A.J. Martin | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2034 | League's Strongest Man | Jason Hodges | Tucson Toros |
| 2033 | Legend of the Game | Louis LaGrange | Miami Talons |
| 2033 | Player of the Year | Isaac Burgess | Detroit Vampires |
| 2033 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Eugene Paulk | Tucson Toros |
| 2033 | Offensive Player of the Year | Isaac Burgess | Detroit Vampires |
| 2033 | Defensive Player of the Year | Norm Curtis | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2033 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | J.R. Brustkern | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2033 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Charles Shepard | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Isaac Burgess | Detroit Vampires |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Running Back | Junior Wolfe | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Fullback | Nate Atkins | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Tight End | Alex Campbell | Tennessee Militia |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Louie Hopkins | Detroit Vampires |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Wally Wooden | Shreveport Pride |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Center | Gabe Tanner | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Sedrick Lundy | Tucson Toros |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Spencer Anderson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Edward Kinney | Hartford Attack |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Randal Panahi | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Punter | Alonzo Spires | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Kicker | David Hjelmar | Tucson Toros |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Jesse Watson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Bob Herriott | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Warren Prescott | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Julio Sturgell | Denver Dynomite |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Walter Josephson | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Norm Curtis | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Mark Seubert | Detroit Vampires |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Marvin Loniewski | Kansas City Storm |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Cornerback | A.J. Woods | Boston Blizzard |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Safety | Joey Stephenson | Miami Talons |
| 2033 | All-League First Team Safety | Arnold Reinert | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Tarzan Hernandez | Hartford Attack |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Hunter Dail | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Tony Abercrombie | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | C.J. Hicks | Boston Blizzard |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Toby Hartman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Center | Roderick Herndon | Detroit Vampires |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Darnell Wyoming | Miami Talons |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Butch Brown | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Brett Brownell | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Marlon Lyons | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Punter | Steven Glover | Ohio Sentries |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Craig Tilt | Detroit Vampires |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Tom Harvey | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Ike Reed | Tucson Toros |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Floyd Pfeiffer | Oregon Bandits |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Tracy Mosby | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Sammy James | Texas Inferno |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Heath Clayton | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Edwin Stoner | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Nick Farr | Oregon Bandits |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Lonnie Megorden | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Safety | Teddy Solymos | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2033 | All-League Second Team Safety | Brant Kasper | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2033 | League's Fastest Man | Rex Stokes | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2033 | League's Strongest Man | J.R. Rudolph | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2032 | Legend of the Game | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2032 | Coach of the Year | Anibal Grover | Detroit Vampires |
| 2032 | Player of the Year | Bart Godfrey | Tennessee Militia |
| 2032 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Blaine Barrett | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2032 | Offensive Player of the Year | Bart Godfrey | Tennessee Militia |
| 2032 | Defensive Player of the Year | Mercury Emmons | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2032 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Stephen Gietka | Hartford Attack |
| 2032 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Joseph Holliday | Boise City Stampede |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Emmanuel Cole | Tennessee Militia |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Running Back | Bart Godfrey | Tennessee Militia |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Fullback | Nate Atkins | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Tight End | Alex Campbell | Tennessee Militia |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Louie Hopkins | Detroit Vampires |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | C.J. Hicks | Boston Blizzard |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Center | Spencer Barnes | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Van Fitzgerald | Tennessee Militia |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Spencer Anderson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | D.J. Scott | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Thomas Lyon | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Punter | Howard Doyle | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Kicker | Antonio Dobler | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Mercury Emmons | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Bob Herriott | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Warren Prescott | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Tracy Mosby | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Luther Howard | Boise City Stampede |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Artie Theophilakos | Hartford Attack |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Joseph Holliday | Boise City Stampede |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Stan Casillas | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Cornerback | R.J. Poffenroth | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Safety | Arnold Reinert | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2032 | All-League First Team Safety | Brant Kasper | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Harry Reese | Texas Inferno |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Junior Wolfe | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Todd Stropka | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Rufus Walsh | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Rusty Schneider | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Skip Upshaw | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Center | Daryl Fagelman | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Norm Layne | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Sedrick Lundy | Tucson Toros |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Cornell Cranga | Tennessee Militia |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Edward Kinney | Denver Dynomite |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Punter | J.R. Choate | Kansas City Storm |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Kicker | John Oates | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Leland Wellins | Shreveport Pride |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Conrad Siavii | Oregon Bandits |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Lamont Gardner | Boise City Stampede |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Jerry Ryder | Detroit Vampires |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Terrance Farley | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Sean Harvey | Hartford Attack |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Ben Singleton | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Renaldo Butler | Shreveport Pride |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Kelvin Bunyan | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Safety | Joey Stephenson | Miami Talons |
| 2032 | All-League Second Team Safety | Anthony Bjorkstam | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2032 | League's Fastest Man | Tommy Abbey | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2032 | League's Strongest Man | Lamont Gardner | Boise City Stampede |
| 2031 | Legend of the Game | Phil Banks | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2031 | Coach of the Year | Anibal Grover | Detroit Vampires |
| 2031 | Player of the Year | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2031 | Front Office Bowl MVP | David Provance | Shreveport Pride |
| 2031 | Offensive Player of the Year | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2031 | Defensive Player of the Year | Leland Wellins | Shreveport Pride |
| 2031 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Dwayne Medley | Tucson Toros |
| 2031 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Terrance Farley | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Running Back | Bart Godfrey | Tennessee Militia |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Fullback | Chris Beyer | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Tight End | Tony Abercrombie | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Rusty Schneider | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Wally Wooden | Shreveport Pride |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Center | Roderick Herndon | Detroit Vampires |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Van Fitzgerald | Tennessee Militia |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | David Briggs | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Cornell Cranga | Tennessee Militia |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Edward Kinney | Denver Dynomite |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Punter | Drew Stokes | Hartford Attack |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Kicker | Antonio Bouler | Boston Blizzard |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Leland Wellins | Shreveport Pride |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Jesse Watson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Warren Prescott | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Tracy Mosby | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Walter Josephson | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Edwin Stoner | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Norm Curtis | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Dave Pettine | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Hugh Hammond | Detroit Vampires |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Safety | Arnold Reinert | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2031 | All-League First Team Safety | Phil Mugica | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Eugene Paulk | Tucson Toros |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Luther Fredrickson | Miami Talons |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Richard Wilson | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Victor Cole | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | C.J. Hicks | Boston Blizzard |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Skip Upshaw | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Center | Shannon Copeland | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Vince Katz | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Brian Stoy | Tucson Toros |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Marlon Lyons | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Brett Brownell | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Punter | Melvin Grant | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Chad Gaytan | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Bob Herriott | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Mercury Emmons | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Brandon Brennan | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Joel Holley | Tennessee Militia |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Nicky Davidson | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Jake Brewer | Texas Inferno |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Herman Fulton | Tucson Toros |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Renaldo Butler | Shreveport Pride |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | A.J. Woods | Boston Blizzard |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Safety | Teddy Solymos | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2031 | All-League Second Team Safety | Courtney Fulton | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2031 | League's Fastest Man | Michael Sage | Texas Inferno |
| 2031 | League's Strongest Man | Warren Prescott | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2030 | Legend of the Game | Shane Hall | Detroit Vampires |
| 2030 | Coach of the Year | Daniel Beane | Tucson Toros |
| 2030 | Player of the Year | Bart Godfrey | Tennessee Militia |
| 2030 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Darrell Winslett | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2030 | Offensive Player of the Year | Bart Godfrey | Tennessee Militia |
| 2030 | Defensive Player of the Year | Leland Wellins | Shreveport Pride |
| 2030 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Junior Wolfe | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2030 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Edwin Stoner | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Running Back | Bart Godfrey | Tennessee Militia |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Fullback | Chris Beyer | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Tight End | Tony Abercrombie | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | C.J. Hicks | Boston Blizzard |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Rusty Schneider | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Center | Spencer Barnes | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Cedric Timm | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | A.J. Beliveau | Denver Dynomite |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Edward Kinney | Denver Dynomite |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Donny Wolf | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Punter | Alonzo Spires | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Kicker | John Oates | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Leland Wellins | Shreveport Pride |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Jesse Watson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Warren Prescott | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Brandon Brennan | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Randy Terrell | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Orlando Bernard | Tucson Toros |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Omar Jordan | Shreveport Pride |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Stan Casillas | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Kelvin Bunyan | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Safety | Courtney Fulton | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2030 | All-League First Team Safety | Joey Hopkins | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Harry Reese | Texas Inferno |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Johnnie Hong | Kansas City Storm |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Don Foley | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Bennie Matson | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | John Yancy | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Skip Upshaw | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Center | Frank Johnstone | Kansas City Storm |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Ray Parmely | Ohio Sentries |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Van Fitzgerald | Tennessee Militia |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Cornell Cranga | Tennessee Militia |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Thomas Lyon | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Punter | Raymond Small | Oregon Bandits |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Tyrus Wooden | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Mercury Emmons | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Bob Herriott | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Desmond Macri | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Matthew Grant | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Walter Josephson | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Corwin Carter | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Sean Harvey | Hartford Attack |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | A.J. Woods | Boston Blizzard |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Nick Farr | Oregon Bandits |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Safety | Brant Kasper | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2030 | All-League Second Team Safety | Arnold Reinert | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2030 | League's Fastest Man | Donnell Sherman | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2030 | League's Strongest Man | Brent Faneca | Kansas City Storm |
| 2029 | Legend of the Game | Dwight Terrell | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2029 | Coach of the Year | Michael McVay | Boston Blizzard |
| 2029 | Player of the Year | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2029 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2029 | Offensive Player of the Year | Irv Finley | Boston Blizzard |
| 2029 | Defensive Player of the Year | Julio Sturgell | Seattle Spartans |
| 2029 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Jim Truglio | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2029 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Herb Money | Boise City Stampede |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Irv Finley | Boston Blizzard |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Running Back | Luther Fredrickson | Miami Talons |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Fullback | Jason Kegley | Ohio Sentries |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Tight End | Rufus Walsh | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | C.J. Hicks | Boston Blizzard |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Rusty Schneider | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Center | Melvin Mayes | Boise City Stampede |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Cory Crawford | Boise City Stampede |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Van Fitzgerald | Tennessee Militia |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | D.J. Scott | Tucson Toros |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Randal Panahi | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Punter | Chad Malek | Seattle Spartans |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Kicker | Norm Doman | Tucson Toros |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Conrad Lang | Hartford Attack |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Johnny Giles | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Julio Sturgell | Seattle Spartans |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Warren Prescott | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Walter Josephson | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Orlando Bernard | Tucson Toros |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | K.C. Brady | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Stan Casillas | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Cornerback | A.J. Woods | Boston Blizzard |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Safety | Kenny Green | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2029 | All-League First Team Safety | Brant Kasper | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Bart Godfrey | Tennessee Militia |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Chris Beyer | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Tony Abercrombie | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Skip Upshaw | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Dwayne Cabbage | Hartford Attack |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Center | Spencer Barnes | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Billy Kramer | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Ray Parmely | Ohio Sentries |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Donald Hickman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Jon Gaylor | Boise City Stampede |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Punter | Dexter Hutton | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Carlton Freeman | Denver Dynomite |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Leland Wellins | Shreveport Pride |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Quentin Gelet | Tennessee Militia |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Tracy Mosby | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Joel Holley | Tennessee Militia |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Randy Terrell | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Sean Harvey | Hartford Attack |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Everett Smithwick | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Ken Watkins | Hartford Attack |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Duane Donovan | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Safety | Craig McQuitty | Oregon Bandits |
| 2029 | All-League Second Team Safety | Kris Fung | Boston Blizzard |
| 2029 | League's Fastest Man | Wally Wooden | Shreveport Pride |
| 2029 | League's Strongest Man | George McCarroll | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2028 | Legend of the Game | Desmond Guajardo | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2028 | Coach of the Year | Mark Lapointe | Tucson Toros |
| 2028 | Player of the Year | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2028 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Max Reichardt | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2028 | Offensive Player of the Year | Gene Woodson | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2028 | Defensive Player of the Year | Artie Theophilakos | Hartford Attack |
| 2028 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Bart Godfrey | Tennessee Militia |
| 2028 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Bill Hammes | Denver Dynomite |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Running Back | Gene Woodson | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Fullback | Mark Wescott | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Tight End | Victor Cole | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Antoine Compton | Oregon Bandits |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | C.J. Hicks | Boston Blizzard |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Center | Spencer Barnes | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Cory Crawford | Boise City Stampede |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Van Fitzgerald | Tennessee Militia |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Edward Kinney | Denver Dynomite |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Richie Ponko | Tucson Toros |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Punter | Rickey Benson | Kansas City Storm |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Kicker | Dixon Finch | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Johnny Giles | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Conrad Lang | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Julio Sturgell | Seattle Spartans |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Matthew Grant | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Claude Gonsalves | Miami Talons |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Artie Theophilakos | Hartford Attack |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Norm Curtis | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Jermaine Chance | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Stan Casillas | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Safety | Arnold Reinert | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2028 | All-League First Team Safety | Doug Farrell | Kansas City Storm |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Don Robbins | Tucson Toros |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Jerald Pritchett | Boise City Stampede |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Jason Kegley | Ohio Sentries |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Rufus Walsh | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Dwayne Cabbage | Hartford Attack |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Wally Wooden | Shreveport Pride |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Center | Daniel Nelson | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Brian Stoy | Tucson Toros |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Billy Kramer | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Phillip Pierce | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | D.J. Scott | Tucson Toros |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Punter | Lionel Grant | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Dexter Bowens | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Ike Reed | Detroit Vampires |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Conrad Siavii | Oregon Bandits |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | George McCarroll | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Warren Prescott | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Tracy Hennek | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Emmitt Schultz | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Cris Jenson | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Duane Donovan | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Marvin Loniewski | Kansas City Storm |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Safety | Joey Hopkins | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2028 | All-League Second Team Safety | Craig McQuitty | Miami Talons |
| 2028 | League's Fastest Man | Donnell Sherman | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2028 | League's Strongest Man | Ernie Hayes | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2027 | Legend of the Game | Corwin Ellard | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2027 | Coach of the Year | Chris Webb | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2027 | Player of the Year | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2027 | Front Office Bowl MVP | David Provance | Boston Blizzard |
| 2027 | Offensive Player of the Year | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2027 | Defensive Player of the Year | Bryce Donaldson | Oregon Bandits |
| 2027 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Luther Fredrickson | Miami Talons |
| 2027 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Jermaine Chance | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Running Back | Graham Burks | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Fullback | Jason Kegley | Ohio Sentries |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Tight End | Victor Cole | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Antoine Compton | Oregon Bandits |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Frank Pritchett | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Center | Daryl Fagelman | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Billy Kramer | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Ernie Hayes | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Donald Hickman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Phillip Pierce | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Punter | D.J. Couch | Kansas City Storm |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Kicker | Shaun Church | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Mercury Emmons | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Johnny Giles | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Matthew Grant | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Julio Sturgell | Seattle Spartans |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Claude Gonsalves | Miami Talons |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Bryce Donaldson | Oregon Bandits |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Tyrus McChane | Miami Talons |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Louis LaGrange | Miami Talons |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Jermaine Chance | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Safety | Phil Mugica | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2027 | All-League First Team Safety | Kris Fung | Boston Blizzard |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Derrick Banner | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Gene Woodson | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Jack Kerr | Shreveport Pride |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Lewis Mikulski | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Barry Reeves | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Phil Banks | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Center | Spencer Barnes | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | David Briggs | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Van Fitzgerald | Tennessee Militia |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Edward Kinney | Denver Dynomite |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | D.J. Scott | Tucson Toros |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Punter | Trevor Pierce | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Tyrus Wooden | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Xavier Black | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Leland Wellins | Shreveport Pride |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Warren Prescott | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Rick Alcott | Shreveport Pride |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Jorge Kaplan | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Austin Wasserman | Detroit Vampires |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Everett Smithwick | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Nick Farr | Oregon Bandits |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Stan Casillas | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Safety | Arnold Reinert | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2027 | All-League Second Team Safety | Doug Farrell | Kansas City Storm |
| 2027 | League's Fastest Man | Wally Wooden | Shreveport Pride |
| 2027 | League's Strongest Man | Randal Gindin | Boston Blizzard |
| 2026 | Legend of the Game | Bernie Copley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2026 | Coach of the Year | Anibal Grover | Detroit Vampires |
| 2026 | Player of the Year | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2026 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2026 | Offensive Player of the Year | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2026 | Defensive Player of the Year | Kris Fung | Boston Blizzard |
| 2026 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Howard Graham | Hartford Attack |
| 2026 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Arnold Reinert | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Running Back | Graham Barrett | Tucson Toros |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Fullback | Mark Wescott | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Tight End | Graham Jacobson | Seattle Spartans |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Antoine Compton | Oregon Bandits |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Bernie Heath | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Center | Quinn Rodgers | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Cedric Timm | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | J.R. Hebert | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | D.J. Scott | Tucson Toros |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Billy Joe Lareche | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Punter | Jason McNeil | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Kicker | Ben Bruner | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Johnny Giles | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Ike Reed | Detroit Vampires |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Warren Prescott | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Cornelius Culpepper | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Kelvin Hartman | Ohio Sentries |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Troy Kornbluth | Detroit Vampires |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Wesley Dotson | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Dave Pettine | Texas Inferno |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Stan Casillas | Kansas City Storm |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Safety | Kris Fung | Boston Blizzard |
| 2026 | All-League First Team Safety | Kenny Green | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Derrick Banner | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Graham Burks | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Jack Kerr | Shreveport Pride |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Broderick Grigsby | Shreveport Pride |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Barry Reeves | Ohio Sentries |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | C.J. Hicks | Boston Blizzard |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Center | Daniel Nelson | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | R.J. Lindblad | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Amos Sorota | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Morris McCarthy | Detroit Vampires |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Phillip Pierce | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Punter | Vernon Calvert | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Dennis de los Santos | Seattle Spartans |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Blake Faulk | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Rusty Chandler | Tucson Toros |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Kerry Floyd | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Nick Baniewicz | Tucson Toros |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Alfred Horn | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | J.C. Morrison | Texas Inferno |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Bernie Harvey | Kansas City Storm |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Rod Burton | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | A.J. Woods | Boston Blizzard |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Safety | Craig McQuitty | Miami Talons |
| 2026 | All-League Second Team Safety | Arnold Reinert | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2026 | League's Fastest Man | Barry Reeves | Ohio Sentries |
| 2026 | League's Strongest Man | Roger Byerly | Oregon Bandits |
| 2025 | Legend of the Game | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2025 | Coach of the Year | Mark Lapointe | Tucson Toros |
| 2025 | Player of the Year | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2025 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Graham Barrett | Tucson Toros |
| 2025 | Offensive Player of the Year | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2025 | Defensive Player of the Year | Joey Hopkins | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2025 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Kevin Hines | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2025 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Donny Forman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Bert Foster | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Running Back | Graham Burks | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Fullback | Bucky Capuco | Detroit Vampires |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Tight End | Robert Moore | Hartford Attack |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Bernie Heath | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Frank Pritchett | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Center | Desmond Guajardo | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Ernie Hayes | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | R.J. Lindblad | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Phillip Pierce | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Marshall Weinstein | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Punter | Gabe Mogilevsky | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Kicker | Shaun Church | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Johnny Giles | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Butch Borders | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | George McCarroll | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Warren Prescott | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Kelvin Hartman | Ohio Sentries |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Wesley Dotson | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Bernie Harvey | Kansas City Storm |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Ronnie Dixon | Tucson Toros |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Morris Crafts | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Safety | Joey Hopkins | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2025 | All-League First Team Safety | Kris Fung | Boston Blizzard |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Edwin Garrett | Texas Inferno |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Winston Mays | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Broderick Grigsby | Shreveport Pride |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Antoine Compton | Oregon Bandits |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Rusty Schneider | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Center | Rodney Pearson | Detroit Vampires |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Amos Sorota | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Cory Crawford | Boise City Stampede |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Cornell Cranga | Tennessee Militia |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Daniel Brandon | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Punter | Jason McNeil | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Casey Gallardo | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Conrad Siavii | Oregon Bandits |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | J.T. Chaky | Seattle Spartans |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Nick Baniewicz | Tucson Toros |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Matthew Grant | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Ian Hailey | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Artie Theophilakos | Hartford Attack |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Jumbo Rockcliffe | Denver Dynomite |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Dave Pettine | Texas Inferno |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Byron Clemons | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Safety | Courtney Fulton | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2025 | All-League Second Team Safety | Tommy Erickson | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2025 | League's Fastest Man | Neal Summers | Tucson Toros |
| 2025 | League's Strongest Man | Herb Rauch | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2024 | Legend of the Game | Lonnie Habich | Boise City Stampede |
| 2024 | Player of the Year | Derrick Banner | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2024 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Derrick Banner | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2024 | Offensive Player of the Year | Derrick Banner | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2024 | Defensive Player of the Year | Herb Welborn | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2024 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Archie Diaz | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2024 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Nicky Davidson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Derrick Banner | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Running Back | Graham Burks | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Fullback | Jason Kegley | Ohio Sentries |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Tight End | Broderick Grigsby | Shreveport Pride |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | C.J. Hicks | Boston Blizzard |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Dwight Terrell | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Center | David Rubio | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Ernie Hayes | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Amos Sorota | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Phillip Pierce | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | D.J. Scott | Tucson Toros |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Punter | Gus Rivers | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Kicker | Darren Wickman | Shreveport Pride |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Monty Kerchner | Tucson Toros |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Defensive End | James Winslett | Denver Dynomite |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Nick Baniewicz | Tucson Toros |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | B.J. Fultz | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Carlos Beito | Hartford Attack |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Herb Welborn | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Artie Theophilakos | Hartford Attack |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Neal Summers | Tucson Toros |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Louis LaGrange | Miami Talons |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Safety | J.R. Chandler | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2024 | All-League First Team Safety | Kris Fung | Boston Blizzard |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Arnie Lanner | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Brady Kaplan | Denver Dynomite |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Graham Jacobson | Seattle Spartans |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Phil Banks | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Ethan Corwin | Miami Talons |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Center | Desmond Guajardo | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Rick Fisher | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Anthony King | Miami Talons |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Darren Singleton | Hartford Attack |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Marshall Weinstein | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Punter | Cornelius Davidson | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Norm Doman | Tucson Toros |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Blake Faulk | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | J.T. Chaky | Seattle Spartans |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Aaron Saunders | Kansas City Storm |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | George McCarroll | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Jorge Kaplan | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Dusty Uribe | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Wesley Dotson | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Dan Burroughs | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Ken Watkins | Hartford Attack |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Safety | Courtney Fulton | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2024 | All-League Second Team Safety | Tommy Erickson | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2024 | League's Fastest Man | Andrew Seelbach | Detroit Vampires |
| 2024 | League's Strongest Man | Rodney Anderson | Seattle Spartans |
| 2023 | Legend of the Game | J.J. Kaeding | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2023 | Coach of the Year | Mark Lapointe | Tucson Toros |
| 2023 | Player of the Year | Derrick Banner | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2023 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Shane Hall | Detroit Vampires |
| 2023 | Offensive Player of the Year | Derrick Banner | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2023 | Defensive Player of the Year | Wesley Dotson | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2023 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | C.J. Hicks | Boston Blizzard |
| 2023 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Artie Theophilakos | Hartford Attack |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Derrick Banner | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Running Back | Arnie Lanner | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Fullback | Bucky Capuco | Detroit Vampires |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Tight End | Devin Lynn | Denver Dynomite |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Barry Reeves | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | C.J. Hicks | Boston Blizzard |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Center | Roosevelt Barber | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Ernie Hayes | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Cedric Timm | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Phillip Pierce | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Marshall Weinstein | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Punter | Irv Fisher | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Kicker | Everett Norton | Kansas City Storm |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Rusty Chandler | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Johnny Giles | Tennessee Militia |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Nick Baniewicz | Tucson Toros |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Eric Shannon | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Steven Metzger | Shreveport Pride |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Wesley Dotson | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Herb Welborn | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Morris Crafts | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Louis LaGrange | Miami Talons |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Safety | Quinn Lessard | Hartford Attack |
| 2023 | All-League First Team Safety | Tyrell Harding | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Edwin Garrett | Texas Inferno |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Jack Kerr | Shreveport Pride |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Broderick Grigsby | Shreveport Pride |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Dwight Terrell | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Phil Banks | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Center | Desmond Guajardo | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Nolan Rauch | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Anthony King | Miami Talons |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Nate Sprehe | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | D.J. Scott | Tucson Toros |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Punter | Gabe Mogilevsky | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Norm Doman | Tucson Toros |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Roosevelt Theriault | Kansas City Storm |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Blake Faulk | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | George McCarroll | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Brian Kellett | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Darnell Lyon | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Bernie Harvey | Kansas City Storm |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Orlando Bernard | Detroit Vampires |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Drew Meier | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Derek Lyle | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Safety | J.R. Chandler | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2023 | All-League Second Team Safety | Kris Fung | Boston Blizzard |
| 2023 | League's Fastest Man | Frank Pritchett | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2023 | League's Strongest Man | Darrin Hopkins | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2022 | Legend of the Game | Casey Reeves | Tucson Toros |
| 2022 | Coach of the Year | Mark Lapointe | Tucson Toros |
| 2022 | Player of the Year | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2022 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2022 | Offensive Player of the Year | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2022 | Defensive Player of the Year | Austin Wasserman | Detroit Vampires |
| 2022 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Mark Takahashi | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2022 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Dexter Barber | Tucson Toros |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Running Back | Arnie Lanner | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Fullback | Monty Warren | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Tight End | Devin Lynn | Denver Dynomite |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Shaun Wirtz | Tucson Toros |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Frank Pritchett | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Center | Marlon Greene | Denver Dynomite |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Anthony King | Miami Talons |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Nolan Rauch | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | D.J. Scott | Tucson Toros |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Marshall Weinstein | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Punter | Alonzo Spires | Miami Talons |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Kicker | Anthony Debaere | Seattle Spartans |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Rusty Chandler | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Defensive End | J.T. Chaky | Seattle Spartans |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Brian Kellett | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Jack Alkateeb | Kansas City Storm |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Kelvin Hartman | Shreveport Pride |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Austin Wasserman | Detroit Vampires |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Herb Welborn | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Ronnie Dixon | Tucson Toros |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Kelvin Fisher | Hartford Attack |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Safety | Kris Fung | Boston Blizzard |
| 2022 | All-League First Team Safety | Doug Farrell | Kansas City Storm |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Shane Hall | Detroit Vampires |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Edwin Garrett | Texas Inferno |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Renaldo Kastilahn | Texas Inferno |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Broderick Grigsby | Shreveport Pride |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Dwight Terrell | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Bernie Heath | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Center | Desmond Guajardo | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Amos Sorota | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | J.R. Hebert | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Bernie Copley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Shawn Clark | Ohio Sentries |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Punter | Gus Rivers | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Antonio Boyd | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Edwin Osborne | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Justin Hatcher | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Grant Bensen | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Jake Emanski | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Sedrick Taggart | Ohio Sentries |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Shaun Trudeau | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Emmitt Schultz | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Jimmie Koslosky | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Emmanuel Graveson | Tucson Toros |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Safety | Andrew Wilson | Tennessee Militia |
| 2022 | All-League Second Team Safety | Tommy Erickson | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2022 | League's Fastest Man | Shaun Wirtz | Tucson Toros |
| 2022 | League's Strongest Man | Eric Shannon | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2021 | Legend of the Game | Jason Noyeaux | Boston Blizzard |
| 2021 | Coach of the Year | Mark Lapointe | Tucson Toros |
| 2021 | Player of the Year | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2021 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2021 | Offensive Player of the Year | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2021 | Defensive Player of the Year | J.T. Chaky | Seattle Spartans |
| 2021 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Edwin Garrett | Texas Inferno |
| 2021 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Craig McQuitty | Miami Talons |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Running Back | Marcus Fortin | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Fullback | Scottie Sumpter | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Tight End | Devin Lynn | Denver Dynomite |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Barry Reeves | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Shaun Wirtz | Tucson Toros |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Center | Quinn Rodgers | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Ernie Hayes | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Todd Ross | Boston Blizzard |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Alonzo St. Amal | Boston Blizzard |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Bernie Copley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Punter | Al Golding | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Kicker | Mack Horner | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Defensive End | J.T. Chaky | Seattle Spartans |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Josh Andrews | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Brian Kellett | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Al Mason | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Desmond Berardi | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Austin Wasserman | Detroit Vampires |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Cornell Rhodes | Hartford Attack |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Brandon Norton | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Dan Burroughs | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Safety | Rodney Horton | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2021 | All-League First Team Safety | Tyrell Harding | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Carl Bradford | Shreveport Pride |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Arnie Lanner | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Monty Warren | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Adam Bridges | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Robbie Schultz | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Dwight Terrell | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Center | Michael Laudenback | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | J.R. Hebert | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Drew Knight | Texas Inferno |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Linwood Donaldson | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Billy Joe Lareche | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Punter | Jack Johnston | Ohio Sentries |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Bert Collins | Ohio Sentries |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Edwin Osborne | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Dusty Blake | Detroit Vampires |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Eric Shannon | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Grant Bensen | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Jorge Kaplan | Boise City Stampede |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Dusty Uribe | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Vince Stephens | Detroit Vampires |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Dana Thomason | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Louis LaGrange | Miami Talons |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Safety | Cornelius Drake | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2021 | All-League Second Team Safety | Andrew Wilson | Tennessee Militia |
| 2021 | League's Fastest Man | Andrew Seelbach | Detroit Vampires |
| 2021 | League's Strongest Man | Bernie Copley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2020 | Legend of the Game | Marcus Garibaldi | Denver Dynomite |
| 2020 | Coach of the Year | Mark Lapointe | Tucson Toros |
| 2020 | Player of the Year | Hunter Walker | Seattle Spartans |
| 2020 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2020 | Offensive Player of the Year | Hunter Walker | Seattle Spartans |
| 2020 | Defensive Player of the Year | Kelvin Hartman | Shreveport Pride |
| 2020 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Toby Broderick | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2020 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | J.R. Chandler | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Hunter Walker | Seattle Spartans |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Running Back | Marcus Fortin | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Fullback | Dexter Cavin | Boise City Stampede |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Tight End | Devin Lynn | Denver Dynomite |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Robbie Schultz | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Barry Reeves | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Center | Casey Reeves | Tucson Toros |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Rick Fisher | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Wesley Carden | Shreveport Pride |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Sam Stortz | Denver Dynomite |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Al Jordan | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Punter | David Prior | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Kicker | Rickey Welbourn | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Defensive End | J.J. Houston | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Roosevelt Theriault | Kansas City Storm |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Eric Shannon | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Warren Zordich | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Kelvin Hartman | Shreveport Pride |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Cornell Rhodes | Hartford Attack |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Austin Wasserman | Boise City Stampede |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Junior Griffith | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Louis LaGrange | Miami Talons |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Safety | Kris Fung | Boston Blizzard |
| 2020 | All-League First Team Safety | Tyrell Harding | Oregon Bandits |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Arnie Lanner | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Renaldo Kastilahn | Texas Inferno |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Graham Jacobson | Seattle Spartans |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Shaun Wirtz | Tucson Toros |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Cornelius Lester | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Center | Michael Laudenback | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Anthony King | Miami Talons |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Darrin Hopkins | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Lonnie Habich | Boise City Stampede |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Nate Sprehe | Kansas City Storm |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Punter | Dwight Castaneda | Boston Blizzard |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Norm Doman | Tucson Toros |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Edwin Osborne | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Josh Andrews | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Hugh Hanks | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Irv Strong | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Bryant Lochtefeld | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Les Nielsen | Tucson Toros |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Shaun Trudeau | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Keith Harrelson | Boston Blizzard |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Andrew Seelbach | Detroit Vampires |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Safety | Rondell Wilkins | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2020 | All-League Second Team Safety | Rodney Horton | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2020 | League's Fastest Man | Frank Pritchett | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2020 | League's Strongest Man | Darrin Hopkins | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2019 | Legend of the Game | K.C. Davis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2019 | Coach of the Year | Mark Lapointe | Tucson Toros |
| 2019 | Player of the Year | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2019 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2019 | Offensive Player of the Year | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2019 | Defensive Player of the Year | Edwin Osborne | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2019 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Arnie Lanner | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2019 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Rick Lichter | Tennessee Militia |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Running Back | Jerome Farrell | Kansas City Storm |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Fullback | Dexter Cavin | Boise City Stampede |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Tight End | Devin Lynn | Denver Dynomite |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Dwight Terrell | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Robbie Schultz | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Center | Trevor Wilder | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Bill Shannon | Ohio Sentries |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Anthony King | Miami Talons |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Lonnie Habich | Boise City Stampede |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Bernie Copley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Punter | Jay Shehee | Shreveport Pride |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Kicker | Everett Norton | Kansas City Storm |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Edwin Osborne | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Irv Wilson | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Eric Shannon | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Toby O'Donnell | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Bryant Lochtefeld | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Austin Wasserman | Boise City Stampede |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Herb Welborn | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Brandon Norton | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Monty Wiley | Tennessee Militia |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Safety | Austin Torres | Shreveport Pride |
| 2019 | All-League First Team Safety | Kim Collins | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Bucky Ferraro | Boise City Stampede |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Jerome Strickland | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Scott McNeil | Hartford Attack |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Adam Bridges | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Nate Mascorella | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Dwight Fling | Tucson Toros |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Center | Desmond Guajardo | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Ted Matsumura | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Bob Wells | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Shane Kudrow | Tucson Toros |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Marshall Weinstein | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Punter | Kim Wayne | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Dominic Jarvis | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Wesley Havran | Tucson Toros |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Dusty Blake | Detroit Vampires |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Hugh Hanks | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Emmitt Head | Boston Blizzard |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Irving Antonick | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Vince Stephens | Detroit Vampires |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Brock Clark | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Morris Crafts | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Josh Jammer | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Safety | Emmanuel Beadnell | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2019 | All-League Second Team Safety | Cornelius Drake | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2019 | League's Fastest Man | Ryan Clark | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2019 | League's Strongest Man | Eric Shannon | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2018 | Legend of the Game | James Oberg | Hartford Attack |
| 2018 | Coach of the Year | Vernon Smith | Boise City Stampede |
| 2018 | Player of the Year | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2018 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Charles Dever | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2018 | Offensive Player of the Year | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2018 | Defensive Player of the Year | Dustin Cineux | Texas Inferno |
| 2018 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Johnny Chiaverini | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2018 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Jorge Kaplan | Boise City Stampede |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Running Back | Roy Jones | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Fullback | Dexter Cavin | Boise City Stampede |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Tight End | Alex Henderson | Miami Talons |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Dwight Terrell | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Tony Crenshaw | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Center | Michael Laudenback | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Brandon Austin | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Kelvin Connell | Tucson Toros |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Bernie Copley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Dexter Cooley | Shreveport Pride |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Punter | Kevin Harmon | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Kicker | Ricky Griffith | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Dustin Cineux | Texas Inferno |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Dusty Blake | Detroit Vampires |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Brandon Lake | Tucson Toros |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Hugh Hanks | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Luke Dunlap | Ohio Sentries |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Alan Leibert | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Brock Clark | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Brandon Norton | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Bill Schulz | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Safety | Rodney Horton | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2018 | All-League First Team Safety | Cornelius Drake | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Donnie Lowe | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Running Back | J.C. Westbrook | Tucson Toros |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Scott McNeil | Hartford Attack |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Adam Bridges | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Ethan Corwin | Miami Talons |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Max Gray | Hartford Attack |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Center | Leroy Quinn | Hartford Attack |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Bill Shannon | Ohio Sentries |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Anthony King | Miami Talons |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Lonnie Habich | Boise City Stampede |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Phillip Terry | Texas Inferno |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Punter | Larry Poole | Boston Blizzard |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Craig Schanding | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Jerald Petrafassi | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Shannon Hutchinson | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Drew Hutchins | Miami Talons |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Melvin McCulloch | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Ian Hailey | Texas Inferno |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Martin Agree | Ohio Sentries |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Kirk Stanton | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Neal Summers | Tucson Toros |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Jay Gohl | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Safety | Andre Kinney | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2018 | All-League Second Team Safety | Tyrell Harding | Oregon Bandits |
| 2018 | League's Fastest Man | Joey Greiner | Oregon Bandits |
| 2018 | League's Strongest Man | Bob Wells | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2017 | Legend of the Game | Branden Lin | Boise City Stampede |
| 2017 | Coach of the Year | Mark Lapointe | Tucson Toros |
| 2017 | Player of the Year | Bucky Ferraro | Boise City Stampede |
| 2017 | Front Office Bowl MVP | J.C. Westbrook | Tucson Toros |
| 2017 | Offensive Player of the Year | Bucky Ferraro | Boise City Stampede |
| 2017 | Defensive Player of the Year | Cornelius Drake | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2017 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Kennedy McIntire | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2017 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Kelvin Hartman | Shreveport Pride |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Bucky Ferraro | Boise City Stampede |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Running Back | Tom Whalen | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Fullback | Maurice Cheney | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Tight End | Carl Covington | Detroit Vampires |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Robbie Schultz | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Glenn Buenaluz | Oregon Bandits |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Center | Trevor Wilder | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Tito Gardner | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Bob Wells | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Bernie Copley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Sam Stortz | Denver Dynomite |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Punter | Scott Owens | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Kicker | Everett Norton | Kansas City Storm |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Edwin Osborne | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Sean Masucci | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Jack Alkateeb | Kansas City Storm |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Al Mason | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Kelvin Hartman | Shreveport Pride |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Brock Clark | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Vince Stephens | Detroit Vampires |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Junior Griffith | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Peter Timlin | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Safety | Cornelius Drake | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2017 | All-League First Team Safety | Irving Sager | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Archie Chasser | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Brady Kaplan | Denver Dynomite |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Devin Lynn | Denver Dynomite |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Morris Hamby | Tennessee Militia |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Scott Satterlee | Kansas City Storm |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Center | Michael Laudenback | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Bill Shannon | Ohio Sentries |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Ted Matsumura | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Lonnie Habich | Boise City Stampede |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Fernando Huntley | Boise City Stampede |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Punter | Orlando Johnstone | Seattle Spartans |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Jeffrey McNeil | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Irv Wilson | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | O.J. James | Boise City Stampede |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Eric Shannon | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Hugh Hanks | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Carlos Beito | Hartford Attack |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Danny Mills | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Martin Agree | Ohio Sentries |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Bobby Giles | Tucson Toros |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Floyd Browning | Miami Talons |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Safety | Grady Barlow | Tucson Toros |
| 2017 | All-League Second Team Safety | Harvey Wilkins | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2017 | League's Fastest Man | Brenden Kapp | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2017 | League's Strongest Man | Ed Cassidy | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2016 | Legend of the Game | Gary Wales | Miami Talons |
| 2016 | Coach of the Year | Mark Lapointe | Tucson Toros |
| 2016 | Player of the Year | Charles Dever | Seattle Spartans |
| 2016 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Marcus Crane | Tucson Toros |
| 2016 | Offensive Player of the Year | Charles Dever | Seattle Spartans |
| 2016 | Defensive Player of the Year | K.C. Kemp | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2016 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Anthony Kerr | Shreveport Pride |
| 2016 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Erik Bronson | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Charles Dever | Seattle Spartans |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Running Back | Roy Jones | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Fullback | Maurice Cheney | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Tight End | Devin Lynn | Denver Dynomite |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Ethan Corwin | Miami Talons |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Ted Tosheff | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Center | Michael Laudenback | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Quinn Punzel | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Danny Wollmuth | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Lonnie Habich | Boise City Stampede |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Tyrus Petrolis | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Punter | Johnny Rodriguez | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Kicker | Norm Doman | Tucson Toros |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Defensive End | J.J. Houston | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Irv Wilson | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Hugh Hanks | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Al Mason | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Troy Whitmore | Kansas City Storm |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | K.C. Kemp | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Jeffrey Whitfield | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Lewis Loukas | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Andre Bailey | Boise City Stampede |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Safety | Robbie Umphenour | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2016 | All-League First Team Safety | Jonathan Brady | Texas Inferno |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Aaron Henke | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Archie Chasser | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Scottie Sumpter | Seattle Spartans |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Alex Henderson | Miami Talons |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Martin O'Neill | Seattle Spartans |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Daniel Willis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Center | Ethan Capoccia | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Kelvin Battle | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Kevin Levine | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Bernie Copley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Sam Stortz | Denver Dynomite |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Punter | Dean Palmer | Texas Inferno |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Lincoln Gillespie | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | O.J. James | Boise City Stampede |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Seth Patton | Miami Talons |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Irv Strong | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Toby O'Donnell | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Kyle Otten | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Brock Clark | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Floyd Terry | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Charles Johnson | Oregon Bandits |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Lance Brewer | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Safety | Daryl Francis | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2016 | All-League Second Team Safety | Grady Barlow | Tucson Toros |
| 2016 | League's Fastest Man | Ernie Cooley | Boise City Stampede |
| 2016 | League's Strongest Man | Donnie Spriggs | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2015 | Legend of the Game | Oliver Fish | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2015 | Coach of the Year | Mark Lapointe | Tucson Toros |
| 2015 | Player of the Year | Archie Chasser | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2015 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Roger Hatcher | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2015 | Offensive Player of the Year | Archie Chasser | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2015 | Defensive Player of the Year | J.J. Houston | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2015 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Daryl Abrams | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2015 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Troy Whitmore | Kansas City Storm |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Running Back | Archie Chasser | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Fullback | Maurice Cheney | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Tight End | Ellis Talley | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Glenn Buenaluz | Oregon Bandits |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Morris Hamby | Tennessee Militia |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Center | Ethan Capoccia | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Cristobal Farias | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Zach Coleman | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Lonnie Habich | Boise City Stampede |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Bernie Copley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Punter | Dean Palmer | Texas Inferno |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Kicker | Rubin Castorena | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Defensive End | J.J. Houston | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Mitch Pike | Miami Talons |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Hugh Hanks | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Toby O'Donnell | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Chad Stadler | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Chuck Newman | Boston Blizzard |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | J.B. Kinney | Hartford Attack |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Brandon Norton | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Cole Giles | Miami Talons |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Safety | Kirk Hardy | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2015 | All-League First Team Safety | Cornelius Drake | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Corwin Ellard | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Tom Whalen | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Emmanuel Morris | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Russell Gitler | Kansas City Storm |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Michael Browning | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Irv Schwartz | Boston Blizzard |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Center | Pat Boucher | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Danny Wollmuth | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Kelvin Battle | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Casey Reinhold | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Craig VanEck | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Punter | Brian Guerin | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Bert Collins | Ohio Sentries |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Ricardo Hauck | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Graham Ragonesi | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Andre Baker | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Kelvin Uzzell | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Reggie Bagley | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Jorge Leone | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Marty Oliver | Oregon Bandits |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Pat Benson | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Marlon John | Denver Dynomite |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Safety | Rodney Horton | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2015 | All-League Second Team Safety | Oliver Fish | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2015 | League's Fastest Man | Glenn Buenaluz | Oregon Bandits |
| 2015 | League's Strongest Man | Zach Coleman | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2014 | Legend of the Game | Gregory Phelan | Boise City Stampede |
| 2014 | Coach of the Year | Vernon Smith | Boise City Stampede |
| 2014 | Player of the Year | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2014 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Floyd Weatherly | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2014 | Offensive Player of the Year | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2014 | Defensive Player of the Year | Mario McLain | Oregon Bandits |
| 2014 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Jerome Strickland | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2014 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Ian Hailey | Texas Inferno |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Kent Goodwin | Tucson Toros |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Running Back | Archie Chasser | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Fullback | Emmanuel Morris | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Tight End | Andrew Bidwell | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Glenn Buenaluz | Oregon Bandits |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Daniel Willis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Center | Ethan Capoccia | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Cristobal Farias | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Bob Wells | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Bernie Copley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Craig VanEck | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Punter | Brian Guerin | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Kicker | Donald Schulman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Marvin Leaf | Boise City Stampede |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Brian Paige | Denver Dynomite |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Harold Stoltzfus | Tucson Toros |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Mario Ah Yat | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Tim Atkins | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Mario McLain | Oregon Bandits |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Jorge Leone | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Danny Rickard | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Charles Johnson | Oregon Bandits |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Safety | Grady Barlow | Tucson Toros |
| 2014 | All-League First Team Safety | Sherman Lee | Hartford Attack |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Branden Lin | Boise City Stampede |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Alan Spearman | Hartford Attack |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Andrew Lincoln | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Kenyon Robinson | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Daniel Patino | Denver Dynomite |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Michael Browning | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Center | Richard Flynn | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Quinn Punzel | Kansas City Storm |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Mark Blair | Miami Talons |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Terrell Jarvis | Tennessee Militia |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Al Jordan | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Punter | Kevin Harmon | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Justin Downs | Oregon Bandits |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Rick Lamontagne | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Darryl Corbett | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Larry Ellis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Irv Strong | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Michael Thibeault | Detroit Vampires |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | K.C. Glode | Seattle Spartans |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Cornell Rhodes | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Warren Donovan | Oregon Bandits |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Cole Giles | Miami Talons |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Safety | David Pitman | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2014 | All-League Second Team Safety | Rex Murch | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2014 | League's Fastest Man | Michael Browning | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2014 | League's Strongest Man | Noah Smyth | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2013 | Legend of the Game | Randolph Downing | Seattle Spartans |
| 2013 | Coach of the Year | Emmanuel Rohr | Seattle Spartans |
| 2013 | Player of the Year | Dwayne Bridges | Boston Blizzard |
| 2013 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Albert Horn | Tucson Toros |
| 2013 | Offensive Player of the Year | Dwayne Bridges | Boston Blizzard |
| 2013 | Defensive Player of the Year | Joel Graziani | Detroit Vampires |
| 2013 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Glenn Buenaluz | Oregon Bandits |
| 2013 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Irving Sager | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Dwayne Bridges | Boston Blizzard |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Running Back | Alan Spearman | Hartford Attack |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Fullback | Maurice Cheney | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Tight End | Wes McGregor | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Michael Browning | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Zachary Spates | Boston Blizzard |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Center | Leonel Lewis | Hartford Attack |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Ted Matsumura | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Kelvin Battle | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Chad Oroumieh | Hartford Attack |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Terrell Jarvis | Tennessee Militia |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Punter | Reuben Dowd | Ohio Sentries |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Kicker | Donald Schulman | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Defensive End | J.J. Houston | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Kasey Cha | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Harold Stoltzfus | Tucson Toros |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Mario Ah Yat | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Kyle Otten | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Joel Graziani | Detroit Vampires |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Mario McLain | Oregon Bandits |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Willie Golalic | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Damon Jankowski | Hartford Attack |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Safety | Jack Upshaw | Denver Dynomite |
| 2013 | All-League First Team Safety | Grady Barlow | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Freddie Mathias | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Archie Chasser | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Bubba Sweeney | Oregon Bandits |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Brian Manos | Detroit Vampires |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Cleveland Coon | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Glenn Buenaluz | Oregon Bandits |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Center | Jason Noyeaux | Boston Blizzard |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Kevin Levine | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Quinn Punzel | Kansas City Storm |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Craig VanEck | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Colin Downs | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Punter | Brian Guerin | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Kicker | B.J. Sutton | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Roger Heflin | Seattle Spartans |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Buster Hall | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Toby O'Donnell | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Melvin McCulloch | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Brady Lanza | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Melvin Dowling | Tennessee Militia |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Mikel Bussard | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Danny Rickard | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Bernie Colston | Hartford Attack |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Safety | David Pitman | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2013 | All-League Second Team Safety | Sherman Lee | Hartford Attack |
| 2013 | League's Fastest Man | Robbie Schultz | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2013 | League's Strongest Man | Toby O'Donnell | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2012 | Legend of the Game | Charles Bergmann | Boise City Stampede |
| 2012 | Player of the Year | Dwayne Bridges | Boston Blizzard |
| 2012 | Front Office Bowl MVP | James Oberg | Hartford Attack |
| 2012 | Offensive Player of the Year | Jeff Reid | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2012 | Defensive Player of the Year | Kris Ober | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2012 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Mario Atkins | Kansas City Storm |
| 2012 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Martin Agree | Boise City Stampede |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Dwayne Bridges | Boston Blizzard |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Running Back | Jeff Reid | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Fullback | George Welton | Miami Talons |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Tight End | Kyle Laxton | Kansas City Storm |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Leroy O'Neal | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Trent Muir | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Center | Earnest Fant | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Kevin Levine | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Daniel Burress | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Marty Covington | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Casey Reinhold | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Punter | Derek Shields | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Kicker | Carson Blume | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Scott Flowers | Detroit Vampires |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Defensive End | J.J. Houston | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Mario Ah Yat | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Dominic Shumpert | Seattle Spartans |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Kris Ober | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Mario McLain | Oregon Bandits |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Deon Flynn | Denver Dynomite |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Genaro Burke | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Damon Jankowski | Miami Talons |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Safety | Oliver Fish | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2012 | All-League First Team Safety | David Pitman | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Al DeNeff | Detroit Vampires |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Alan Spearman | Hartford Attack |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Bubba Sweeney | Oregon Bandits |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Tight End | T.J. Green | Tennessee Militia |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Michael Browning | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Zachary Spates | Boston Blizzard |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Center | Leonel Lewis | Hartford Attack |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Cristobal Farias | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Kenneth Claypoole | Kansas City Storm |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Harold Schmidt | Denver Dynomite |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Lance Lukas | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Punter | Nolan Grooms | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Everett Norton | Kansas City Storm |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Ronnie Huey | Texas Inferno |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Andrew Russel | Hartford Attack |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Matthew D'Ottavio | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Andre Baker | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Tim Atkins | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Jamaal Manning | Hartford Attack |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Mikel Bussard | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Peter Timlin | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Leo Parks | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Safety | Kirk Hardy | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2012 | All-League Second Team Safety | Horace Shuck | Shreveport Pride |
| 2012 | League's Fastest Man | Leo Parks | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2012 | League's Strongest Man | Daryl Wilk | Miami Talons |
| 2011 | Legend of the Game | Paul Dover | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2011 | Player of the Year | Butch Fulton | Texas Inferno |
| 2011 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Drew Holliday | Tucson Toros |
| 2011 | Offensive Player of the Year | Butch Fulton | Texas Inferno |
| 2011 | Defensive Player of the Year | Rocky Alleman | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2011 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Austin Philyaw | Boise City Stampede |
| 2011 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | J.C. Harvey | Kansas City Storm |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Charles Dever | Seattle Spartans |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Running Back | Butch Fulton | Texas Inferno |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Fullback | George Welton | Miami Talons |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Tight End | Gerald Thorpe | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Rueben Albertson | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Michael Browning | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Center | Corey Fulbright | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Kelvin Battle | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Kevin Levine | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Larry Peters | Detroit Vampires |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Marty Covington | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Punter | Derek Shields | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Kicker | Frederic Swallow | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Kasey Cha | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Rick Lamontagne | Texas Inferno |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Dominic Shumpert | Seattle Spartans |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Larry Ellis | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Charles Reed | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Mikel Bussard | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Jeffrey Whitfield | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Willie Golalic | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Devin Hopper | Kansas City Storm |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Safety | Rocky Alleman | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2011 | All-League First Team Safety | Michael Hubbard | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Edward Kimber | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Jeff Reid | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Tom Grafton | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Frederick Abeyta | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Jamie Atkins | Kansas City Storm |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Chris Chavez | Oregon Bandits |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Center | Tony Baker | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Lawrence Walters | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Danilo Biddle | Texas Inferno |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Craig VanEck | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Lance Lukas | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Punter | Brock Lightfoot | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Bryce Goodwin | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | J.J. Houston | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Scott Flowers | Detroit Vampires |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Andre Baker | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Mercury Gil | Tennessee Militia |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Tim Atkins | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Richie Haynesworth | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Mario McLain | Kansas City Storm |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Mark Tatum | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Clyde Alston | Tennessee Militia |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Safety | Oliver Fish | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2011 | All-League Second Team Safety | Bobby Miller | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2011 | League's Fastest Man | Arnie Pritchett | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2011 | League's Strongest Man | Jerald Barber | Shreveport Pride |
| 2010 | Legend of the Game | Zachery Aaron | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2010 | Coach of the Year | Victor Ginn | Denver Dynomite |
| 2010 | Player of the Year | Butch Fulton | Texas Inferno |
| 2010 | Front Office Bowl MVP | James Oberg | Hartford Attack |
| 2010 | Offensive Player of the Year | Butch Fulton | Texas Inferno |
| 2010 | Defensive Player of the Year | Kris Ober | Ohio Sentries |
| 2010 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Marvin Raffo | Miami Talons |
| 2010 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Jeffrey Whitfield | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Quarterback | James Oberg | Hartford Attack |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Running Back | Butch Fulton | Texas Inferno |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Fullback | George Welton | Miami Talons |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Tight End | Brian Manos | Detroit Vampires |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Michael Browning | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Abe Muncy | Boise City Stampede |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Center | Jason Noyeaux | Boston Blizzard |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Kevin Levine | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Judson Broadnax | Kansas City Storm |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | J.R. Franz | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Joel Cheeks | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Punter | Gus Rivers | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Kicker | Darrell Styblo | Seattle Spartans |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Buster Hall | Seattle Spartans |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Roger Heflin | Seattle Spartans |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Mario Ah Yat | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Larry Ellis | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Kris Ober | Ohio Sentries |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Tommy Eby | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Jerrod Spalding | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Chris Groom | Shreveport Pride |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Nathan Unknow | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Safety | John Murguia | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2010 | All-League First Team Safety | Alvin McCloskey | Ohio Sentries |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Charles Dever | Seattle Spartans |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Archie Chasser | Kansas City Storm |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Anton Ervin | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Anthony Torres | Tucson Toros |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Rueben Albertson | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Kelley McCaleb | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Center | Gary Wales | Miami Talons |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Kelvin Battle | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Marlon Fitzgerald | Hartford Attack |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Chad Oroumieh | Hartford Attack |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Craig VanEck | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Punter | Brock Lightfoot | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Felton Cooper | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Pierre Hinson | Kansas City Storm |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Andrew Russel | Hartford Attack |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Kendrick Gunn | Kansas City Storm |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Dominic Shumpert | Seattle Spartans |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Tim Atkins | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Victor Ginn | Miami Talons |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Hassan Rea | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Willie Golalic | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Genaro Burke | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Safety | Calvin Bush | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2010 | All-League Second Team Safety | David Pitman | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2010 | League's Fastest Man | Gregory Rice | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2010 | League's Strongest Man | Cristobal Farias | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2009 | Legend of the Game | Alfonzo Levine | Ohio Sentries |
| 2009 | Coach of the Year | Vernon Smith | Boise City Stampede |
| 2009 | Player of the Year | Butch Fulton | Miami Talons |
| 2009 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Marcus Garibaldi | Denver Dynomite |
| 2009 | Offensive Player of the Year | Butch Fulton | Miami Talons |
| 2009 | Defensive Player of the Year | Tim Atkins | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2009 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Archie Chasser | Kansas City Storm |
| 2009 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Bernie Grisham | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Charles Dever | Seattle Spartans |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Running Back | Butch Fulton | Miami Talons |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Fullback | Tom Grafton | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Tight End | Brian Manos | Detroit Vampires |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Tom Sonkin | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Michael Browning | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Center | Herman Tarver | Detroit Vampires |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Kim Honeycutt | Oregon Bandits |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Rocky Dayton | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Lance Lukas | Tennessee Militia |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Leroy Banks | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Punter | Nolan Grooms | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Kicker | Carson Blume | Tennessee Militia |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Zachery Aaron | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Scott Flowers | Detroit Vampires |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Matthew D'Ottavio | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Harold Stoltzfus | Tucson Toros |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Tim Atkins | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Teddy Yuan | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Brian Macaluso | Oregon Bandits |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Casey Duran | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Willie Golalic | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Safety | David Pitman | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2009 | All-League First Team Safety | Clay Campbell | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Branden Lin | Boise City Stampede |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Burt Liszkiewicz | Seattle Spartans |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Rufus Eklund | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Daniel Gendron | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Kelley McCaleb | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Cole Faison | Seattle Spartans |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Center | Robbie Sutton | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | David Crew | Miami Talons |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Don Gardner | Denver Dynomite |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | K.C. Davis | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Matthew Pitman | Tucson Toros |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Punter | Omar Ackerman | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Felton Cooper | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Kasey Cha | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Conrad Pellegrini | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Melvin Beamon | Denver Dynomite |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Albert Poole | Hartford Attack |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Henry Pittman | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Ira Saxon | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Mark Wilk | Denver Dynomite |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Charles Spry | Boise City Stampede |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Genaro Burke | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Safety | Hans Walton | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2009 | All-League Second Team Safety | Alvin McCloskey | Ohio Sentries |
| 2009 | League's Fastest Man | Arnie Pritchett | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2009 | League's Strongest Man | Daniel Braddy | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2008 | Legend of the Game | Kevin Deck | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2008 | Coach of the Year | Victor Ginn | Denver Dynomite |
| 2008 | Player of the Year | Arthur Brady | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2008 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Landon Hurst | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2008 | Offensive Player of the Year | Butch Fulton | Miami Talons |
| 2008 | Defensive Player of the Year | Adrian Queen | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2008 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Ernie Cooley | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2008 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Ricardo Campo | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Branden Lin | Boise City Stampede |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Running Back | Butch Fulton | Miami Talons |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Fullback | George Welton | Miami Talons |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Tight End | Randolph Downing | Seattle Spartans |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Kelley McCaleb | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Abe Muncy | Boise City Stampede |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Center | Earnest Fant | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Judson Broadnax | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Ross Tessier | Boston Blizzard |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Richard Davis | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | David To | Texas Inferno |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Punter | Phillip Holdgate | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Kicker | Ricky Griffith | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Zachery Aaron | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Horace Williams | Tennessee Militia |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Harold Stoltzfus | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Andrew Thom | Ohio Sentries |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Adrian Queen | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Teddy Yuan | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Jeffrey Weinstein | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Willie Golalic | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Adolph Means | Ohio Sentries |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Safety | David Pitman | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2008 | All-League First Team Safety | John Murguia | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Dwayne Bridges | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Arthur Brady | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Matthew Renn | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Delbert Lonergan | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Jarvis Huntsman | Kansas City Storm |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Tom Sonkin | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Center | Robbie Sutton | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Danilo Biddle | Texas Inferno |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Steven Odum | Tucson Toros |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Leroy Banks | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Russell Tollefson | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Punter | Jonathan Grays | Tennessee Militia |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Craig Schanding | Oregon Bandits |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Brian Paige | Hartford Attack |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Fredric Diggs | Oregon Bandits |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Mario Ah Yat | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Melvin Beamon | Denver Dynomite |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Johnie Nobles | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Joseph Watford | Tucson Toros |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | James Gregor | Shreveport Pride |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Mark Tatum | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Erwin Koch | Shreveport Pride |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Safety | Michael Hubbard | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2008 | All-League Second Team Safety | Tony Blank | Kansas City Storm |
| 2008 | League's Fastest Man | Ernie Cooley | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2008 | League's Strongest Man | Michael Jackson | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2007 | Legend of the Game | Rodrick Clarke | Shreveport Pride |
| 2007 | Coach of the Year | Michael Nelson | Hartford Attack |
| 2007 | Player of the Year | Arthur Brady | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2007 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Marcus Garibaldi | Denver Dynomite |
| 2007 | Offensive Player of the Year | Alexis Rounds | Texas Inferno |
| 2007 | Defensive Player of the Year | Louis Kratzer | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2007 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Alan Spearman | Hartford Attack |
| 2007 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Robbie Umphenour | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Philip Barbieri | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Running Back | Alexis Rounds | Texas Inferno |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Fullback | Anton Ervin | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Tight End | Brian Manos | Detroit Vampires |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Matt Brunner | Oregon Bandits |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Kelley McCaleb | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Center | Refugio Davis | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Danilo Biddle | Texas Inferno |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Judson Broadnax | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Jaime Barnard | Boston Blizzard |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Noah Smyth | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Punter | Kim Wayne | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Kicker | J.C. Adkins | Ohio Sentries |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Buster Hall | Seattle Spartans |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Zachery Aaron | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Dominic Shumpert | Seattle Spartans |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Zack Shirley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Louis Kratzer | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Chris Millsaps | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Brian Macaluso | Oregon Bandits |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Genaro Burke | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Leo Parks | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Safety | Justin Luck | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2007 | All-League First Team Safety | Will Rodriguez | Boston Blizzard |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Charles Dever | Seattle Spartans |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Arthur Brady | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Fullback | George Welton | Miami Talons |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Tight End | John Vandenberg | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Cole Faison | Seattle Spartans |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Tony Oaks | Ohio Sentries |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Center | Mike Kenney | Tennessee Militia |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Hunter Jaimes | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Van Eicher | Boston Blizzard |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Craig Fecteau | Texas Inferno |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Larry Cawley | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Punter | Nolan Grooms | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Kicker | John Snell | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Bob McCalla | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Andrew Russel | Hartford Attack |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Harold Stoltzfus | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Derick Javier | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Adrian Queen | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Victor Ginn | Boise City Stampede |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Jesse Reyes | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Sedrick Boyd | Kansas City Storm |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Erwin Koch | Shreveport Pride |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Safety | Mitchel Enoch | Tucson Toros |
| 2007 | All-League Second Team Safety | Hans Walton | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2007 | League's Fastest Man | Keven Biggs | Tucson Toros |
| 2007 | League's Strongest Man | Robert Russell | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2006 | Legend of the Game | Andy Gourley | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2006 | Coach of the Year | Stephen Vanhook | Detroit Vampires |
| 2006 | Player of the Year | Dwayne Bridges | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2006 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Ronnie Tu | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2006 | Offensive Player of the Year | Charles Dever | Seattle Spartans |
| 2006 | Defensive Player of the Year | Jesse Reyes | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2006 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Drew Holliday | Tucson Toros |
| 2006 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Mario Ah Yat | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Charles Dever | Seattle Spartans |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Running Back | Sherman New | Boise City Stampede |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Fullback | Paris Kimmel | Seattle Spartans |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Tight End | Brian Manos | Detroit Vampires |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Matt Brunner | Oregon Bandits |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Ronald Tibbetts | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Center | David Pless | Tucson Toros |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Judson Broadnax | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Hunter Jaimes | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Jaime Barnard | Boston Blizzard |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Gregory Williams | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Punter | Matthew Rhodes | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Kicker | Rubin Castorena | Tucson Toros |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Pierre Hinson | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Jerrold Moton | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Dominic Shumpert | Seattle Spartans |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Mark Coleman | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Amos King | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Jesse Reyes | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Alfonzo Levine | Ohio Sentries |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Bennie Seawright | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Genaro Burke | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Safety | Michael Hubbard | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2006 | All-League First Team Safety | Tony Blank | Kansas City Storm |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Dwayne Bridges | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Arthur Brady | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Anton Ervin | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Delbert Lonergan | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | James Doney | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Cleveland Coon | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Center | Tony Baker | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Hershel McArdle | Seattle Spartans |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Kim Honeycutt | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Russell Tollefson | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Kenneth Claypoole | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Punter | Nolan Grooms | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Eliseo Frame | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Rick Lamontagne | Texas Inferno |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | David Askins | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Zack Shirley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Harold Stoltzfus | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | James Silver | Ohio Sentries |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Mark Wilk | Denver Dynomite |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Chris Millsaps | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Marcus Mebane | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Erwin Koch | Shreveport Pride |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Safety | Earnest Pettiford | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2006 | All-League Second Team Safety | Paul Dover | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2006 | League's Fastest Man | Nathan Unknow | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2006 | League's Strongest Man | Mark Blair | Detroit Vampires |
| 2005 | Legend of the Game | Timothy Gordon | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2005 | Coach of the Year | Anibal Grover | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2005 | Player of the Year | Arthur Brady | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2005 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Ronnie Tu | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2005 | Offensive Player of the Year | Arthur Brady | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2005 | Defensive Player of the Year | Nickolas Snodgrass | Miami Talons |
| 2005 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Toothpick Lang | Ohio Sentries |
| 2005 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Edgar Raymond | Boise City Stampede |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Ronnie Tu | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Running Back | Arthur Brady | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Fullback | Orlando Scott | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Tight End | Erich Frazee | Hartford Attack |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Mikel Rice | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Jermaine Stroman | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Center | Robbie Sutton | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Ross Tessier | Boston Blizzard |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Hunter Jaimes | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Jaime Barnard | Boston Blizzard |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Michael Nelson | Boston Blizzard |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Punter | Dorsey Danner | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Kicker | Eliseo Frame | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Casey Bousquet | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Fredric Diggs | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Zack Shirley | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Jacques Haggard | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Nickolas Snodgrass | Miami Talons |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Jesse Reyes | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Alfonzo Levine | Ohio Sentries |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Craig Jiles | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Keven Biggs | Tucson Toros |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Safety | Elijah Roy | Ohio Sentries |
| 2005 | All-League First Team Safety | Hans Walton | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | James Oberg | Hartford Attack |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Sherman New | Boise City Stampede |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Fullback | August Wick | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Delbert Lonergan | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Efren Herold | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Curtis Plotkin | Hartford Attack |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Center | Theo Garcia | Denver Dynomite |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Thomas Paddock | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Kim Honeycutt | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Kenneth Claypoole | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Loren Creekmore | Shreveport Pride |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Punter | Matthew Rhodes | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Rubin Castorena | Tucson Toros |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Bob McCalla | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Seth Keller | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Gary Davis | Denver Dynomite |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | David Specht | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Ervin Chapman | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Garth Dittman | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | James Gregor | Shreveport Pride |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Damon Jankowski | Miami Talons |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Ismael Edwards | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Safety | Jack Upshaw | Denver Dynomite |
| 2005 | All-League Second Team Safety | Eric Paige | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2005 | League's Fastest Man | Adolph Means | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2005 | League's Strongest Man | Chris Sandidge | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2004 | Legend of the Game | Mark Horrocks | Tennessee Militia |
| 2004 | Coach of the Year | Thomas Sharp | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2004 | Player of the Year | Timothy Gordon | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2004 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Timothy Gordon | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2004 | Offensive Player of the Year | Timothy Gordon | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2004 | Defensive Player of the Year | Colby Stoner | Ohio Sentries |
| 2004 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Butch Fulton | Miami Talons |
| 2004 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | K.C. Glode | Seattle Spartans |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Timothy Gordon | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Running Back | Chester Brumley | Tucson Toros |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Fullback | Thanh Cupp | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Tight End | Cleveland Peterkin | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Rueben Albertson | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Kelley McCaleb | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Center | Charles Bergmann | Boise City Stampede |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Kim Honeycutt | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Ross Tessier | Boston Blizzard |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Jaime Barnard | Boston Blizzard |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Lance Lukas | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Punter | Andrew Schrimsher | Boston Blizzard |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Kicker | Gary Hutchins | Denver Dynomite |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Horace Williams | Tennessee Militia |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Casey Bousquet | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Chester Reed | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Dominic Shumpert | Seattle Spartans |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Colby Stoner | Ohio Sentries |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Garth Dittman | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Jeffrey Weinstein | Fargo Sodbusters |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Cornerback | James Nichols | Boston Blizzard |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Marcus Mebane | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Safety | Justin Luck | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2004 | All-League First Team Safety | John Murguia | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Landon Hurst | Oregon Bandits |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Rodger Rubenstein | Oregon Bandits |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Carson Millsaps | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Steven Smith | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Zachary Spates | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Jody Beech | Hartford Attack |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Center | Theo Garcia | Denver Dynomite |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | William Gregg | Tucson Toros |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Thomas Paddock | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Gregory Williams | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Kenneth Claypoole | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Punter | Charles Welch | Detroit Vampires |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Tobias Paschal | Tennessee Militia |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Ralph Crank | Santa Cruz Privateers |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Zachery Duggan | Denver Dynomite |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Mark Coleman | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Albert Poole | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Nickolas Snodgrass | Miami Talons |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Hollis Beardsley | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | James Gregor | Shreveport Pride |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Charlie Weems | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Craig Jiles | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Safety | Elijah Roy | Ohio Sentries |
| 2004 | All-League Second Team Safety | Desmond Ward | Miami Talons |
| 2004 | League's Fastest Man | Cole Faison | Seattle Spartans |
| 2004 | League's Strongest Man | Michael Nelson | Boston Blizzard |
| 2003 | Legend of the Game | Kerry Herod | Oregon Bandits |
| 2003 | Coach of the Year | Thomas Sharp | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2003 | Player of the Year | Timothy Gordon | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2003 | Front Office Bowl MVP | Landon Hurst | Oregon Bandits |
| 2003 | Offensive Player of the Year | Chester Brumley | Tucson Toros |
| 2003 | Defensive Player of the Year | Louis Evan | Boise City Stampede |
| 2003 | Offensive Rookie of the Year | Brett McDaniel | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2003 | Defensive Rookie of the Year | Michael Thibeault | Detroit Vampires |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Quarterback | Landon Hurst | Oregon Bandits |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Running Back | Chester Brumley | Tucson Toros |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Fullback | Thanh Cupp | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Tight End | Lincoln Denning | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Matt Brunner | Oregon Bandits |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Wide Receiver | John Gunter | Kansas City Storm |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Center | Robbie Sutton | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Paris Johnson | Shreveport Pride |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Robert Russell | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Jaime Barnard | Boston Blizzard |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Richard Davis | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Punter | Earle Cabral | Death Valley Copperheads |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Kicker | Joseph Dunford | New Orleans Voodoo |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Seth Keller | Atlantic City Phantoms |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Defensive End | Casey Bousquet | Alaska Kodiaks |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Lauren Tilghman | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | David Specht | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Louis Evan | Boise City Stampede |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Garth Dittman | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Don Brack | Miami Talons |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Chris Wilber | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Cornerback | Marcus Mebane | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Safety | Carl Stine | Texas Inferno |
| 2003 | All-League First Team Safety | Hoyt Graham | Kansas City Storm |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Quarterback | Timothy Gordon | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Running Back | Ben Everson | Atlanta Firebirds |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Fullback | Jeffery Earp | Tennessee Militia |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Tight End | Dane McCrae | Tennessee Militia |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Nestor Lambrecht | Los Angeles Outlaws |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Jerome Stearns | San Antonio Stingers |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Center | James Caines | Las Vegas Rounders |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Rocky Dayton | Boise City Stampede |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Hunter Jaimes | Durham Bulldogs |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Gregory Williams | Omaha Arrowheads |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Larry Cawley | Baltimore Bombers |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Punter | Brian Hazel | Brooklyn Brawlers |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Kicker | Carson Blume | Shreveport Pride |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Brian Vanegas | Oregon Bandits |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Defensive End | Isaiah Melo | Tennessee Militia |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Derick Javier | Philadelphia Generals |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Jacques Haggard | Ohio Sentries |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Nickolas Snodgrass | Miami Talons |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Alfonzo Levine | Ohio Sentries |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Hollis Beardsley | Iowa City Argonauts |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Adolph Means | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Cornerback | Russ Poole | Kansas City Storm |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Safety | John Murguia | Honolulu Sharks |
| 2003 | All-League Second Team Safety | Benjamin Montalvo | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2003 | League's Fastest Man | Wilton Burgess | St. Louis Silverbacks |
| 2003 | League's Strongest Man | Chris Bahr | Alaska Kodiaks |